Quote:
Originally Posted by Havelock As far as the party system goes, I wholeheartedly agree that we need to make additional parties viable. But in an electoral system like ours, Condorcet's Law (misnamed because it isn't actually a law) strongly suggests that factions will polarize into two parties. The system may deform every now and again to accommodate a third party, or even a fourth, but in general it's a two-party system. The way to get around this without switching to something like proportional representation is to change the voting rules to something like approval voting or the single transferable vote. The change would have to come state-by-state, which is good in that you could test it out first to make sure it works and let the rest of the country get an idea of what a preferential voting system looks like. Big changes like that generally ought to happen gradually. |
The bad thing about a more than two party system is that in the end you'll have two coalitions of parties (2 vs 2 or 10 vs 10 doesn't really matter), where, the smaller one will rule the country just by threatening to leave the coalition. I see this happen often where I live and it's the worst thing that could happen overall. Two parties, for how sad this can be, are the best compromise.