Quote:
Originally Posted by Sunder  Note: These assume 100% healthy
Payton Manning
Tom Brady
Carson Palmer
Brett Favre
Drew Brees
Donovan McNabb
Marc Bulger
Tony Romo
Phillip Rivers
Ben Roethlisberger
Matt Hasselbeck
Jon Kitna
Jeff Garcia
J.P. Lossman
Alex Smith
Chad Pennington
Jay Cutler
Matt Leinart
Vince Young
Jake Delhomme
Steve McNair
Matt Shaub
Eli Manning
Trent Green
Jason Campbell
Damon Huard
David Garrard
Derek Anderson
Rex Grossman
Tarvaris Jackson
Joey Harrington
{insert Oakland QB here} |
Seriously HOW THE FUCK can you rate Manning OVER Brady? I maybe be a biased Pats fan but NFL commentators say that Brady is the 3rd or 4th best QB of all time behind Montana and Elway. I think Manning is 7th or 8th on that list. Brady has 3 Super Bowl rings. He has driven his team down the field in under 2 minutes at the end of Super Bowls to win games. He is a leader and is cool under pressure. I will take Brady over any other QB currently in the NFL any day. The only reason Manning won 1 Super Bowl is because Brady had absolutely shit receivers last year, if Brady had Deion Branch last year they would have won the Super Bowl. And big whoop, Manning won 1 Super Bowl ring vs the Bears and REX GROSSMAN, talk to me when he atleast has 2 rings. Any chump can get lucky and win 1. Also, look what Brady is doing now (In his first 3 games) when he finally has some good receivers. Manning has had Reggie Wayne and Marvin Harrinson 2 of the top 10 receivers in the league, Brady had Rasheed Caldwell and an old Troy brown. I am not saying that Manning sucks, he is great and the 2nd best QB in the NFL but he is not better than Brady.
The only thing Manning beats Brady at is selling out and doing 10,000 commercials per year.