Quote:
Originally Posted by Twobit Whore  I can't think of more than 5 or 6 teams that Eli could start for. Which is 3 or 4 more than Grossman could start for. |
I'll list starting QBs Eli is better (In no particular order):
Alex Smith
Matt Leinart
Rex Grossman
Tavaris Jackson/Kelly Holcomb
Jason Cambell
Joey Harrington
Chad Pennington
JP Losman
Derek Anderson
Kyle Boller (and Steve McNair of 2007)
Jay Cutler (Has great upside, but he's not there yet.)
Josh McCown
Damon Huard
David Garrard
The following QBs are just as good if not just a little better/little worse than Eli.
Matt Shaub
Big Ben
Phillip Rivers
Jeff Garcia
Jon Kitna
Tony Romo
Jake Delhomme
I would say Tony Romo is better and Jake Delhomme (though he was down right awful last year), Kitna and Garcia is a little worse and Ben and Phillip are just about the same. I have to see more than 3 games from Matt Shaub to really say better or worse. You can rank them differently each week. If Tony Romo continues to play like he is, he'll move to the next catagory. I'd really like to see Tony Romo play from behind. He has a great TE and WR along with a great O-Line.
QBs better than Eli:
Matt Hasslebeck
Marc Bulger
Brett Favre
Donavan McNabb
Drew Brees (What's going on with him right now?)
Carson Palmer
Tom Brady
Trent Green
P.Manning
I don't know where to put Vince Young. As a pure QB Eli is better. Though V.Young is a superior athlete.